Post from Whitney on actions... Subject: Re: [pnpgm] Game Update #48 - File #431 - Tiehul's Revelation X-BeenThere: pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl Whitney grimaces, "Trust me, there is no such thing as a 'natural magic'. Well, maybe 3 items. But anything that requires a spell to activate is less than natural, by definition. Well, linguistic definition, in any event. With a paltry handful exceptions, the whole category misnamed as 'natural magic' is little more than a collection of artificial magic items that simply require the casting of a spell, rather than the casting of a spell after a bit of crafting. Natural, but not magic. Of the remainder, such as the rock hard eye of a demon (which isn't even a gem, but an animal part, more or less) or the sap of a Balance March botanical humanoid, some are magic but far from natural. Truly natural magics do exist, but you can count them ont he fingers of one hand. Even of you don't have a full set. "Which just goes to show that even mages and wizards can be sloppy scholars, if not outright linguistically incompetent. Why with all those supernatural languages they learn, you'd think they'd actually recognize two words with opposing meanings always cropping up in their studies. Idiots. Next they'll be saying the various languages of magic power spells because the gods have decreed it so. There should be an intelligence test to learn spellcasting." Whitney's voice trails off as he mutters to himself about the general lack of scholarly acumen in the modern wizard. OOC: I'd like to thank you for finally bring up the topic of natural magics, and even going the extra mile of mentioning spells in conjunction with the term. I've been saving that rant for 6 months, since I created the character, although I cut it down by 4 paragraphs just so the locals helping us didn't decide to turn Whitney in as a crazy person. :-) Anyone want to reopen the supernatural language discussion you had just before he joined? :-) > Raban smiles, "That may be a great idea, assuming those are not >watched as places suspected of being magic related. Knowing what is >accepted could be very important. My knowledge of such things is greatly >limited. My teacher told me about various natural magics I would find >useful, but not in much detail nor what spells were needed to use them. >I had to purchase the ones I could locate, ready to use. I can recognize >quite a few medicinal plants and herbs as well as those useful in >massages, so my herbalism lore is limited... I think it would draw too >much attention if I visited such a place and from the size of the people >here, it is unlikely I would fit inside such a shop." > >_______________________________________________ >pnpgm mailing list >pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl >http://abroere.xs4all.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pnpgm Thank you for your time, Thomas O. Magann Jr. _______________________________________________ pnpgm mailing list pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl Subject: Re: [pnpgm] Game Update #48 - File #431 - Tiehul's Revelation X-BeenThere: pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl Whitney shakes his head, "Oh, I understand your point, and I agree, more or less. That's what I was saying, as my recent unfortunate incarceration proves: hether it's really magic or not doesn't matter, just whether the local magic-hating constabulary considers it magic. My point is: let's learn from my hard won lesson and avoid using plants that aren't sold by local apothecaries. "Oh, and for the record: I know more than a little about plants, magical and otherwise. Hell, I know damned near everything, particularly whether I've magicked one up or not while preparing it for use. I DO worry about just those details, and have written monographs on them and the very contradiction in the woefully misnamed 'Natural Magic' field. Talk about your oxymorons... "Oh, come to think of it, maybe we should find out what's sold by the local apothecaries, so we know what's safe to use." > > Thomas O. Magann Jr. wrote: >> Though I suppose >> >>> something could be made from plants and herbs which could help in that, >>> is that magic?" >>> >> >> Whitney chimes in with a sour look on his face, No, no it isn't, usually. And I wish more people would realize that. Especially local magistrates." >> >> > Raban sighs, "No you missed what I said. More powerful effects such as >making someone stronger may be magical. So many plants have magical >applications but if you use magic to bring out that ability is the plant >itself magical? Some plants are inherently magical while others are not. >So is there some that bring out powerful effects that are not magical >and do not need magic to produce results. My teacher never worried about >those details so I do not know for sure. I also cannot see magic like >some do so I cannot easily verify if the plant is magical. For massages >and healing, there are many plants that help greatly and do not need >magic to process. Others that are more effective use spells to bring out >that ability. They are used the same way so I would not be sure when I >am using a magical version or not. So I can understand how others may >declare all such use is magic even when it is not. It is always >difficult when someones skill assisted by plants, herbs or oils and can >cure things without use of magic. How would someone know they did not >use magic? I am afraid that here they will assume anything effective is >magic and not because of years of training and practice. But what if >your training actually brought out some magical talent and you did not >know it? Can you be sure you are not adding something more than skill?" > > >_______________________________________________ >pnpgm mailing list >pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl >http://abroere.xs4all.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pnpgm Thank you for your time, Thomas O. Magann Jr. _______________________________________________ pnpgm mailing list pnpgm@abroere.xs4all.nl http://abroere.xs4all.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pnpgm